top of page

Book Review: INSIDE PHILANTHROPY

Sep 5, 2025
1 min read

Updated: Sep 7, 2025


Mike Scutari - January 13, 2025


Slowly but surely, participatory grantmaking, loosely defined as the practice in which a funder hands off elements of the grantmaking process to external individuals, has burrowed its way into the philanthrosphere’s collective consciousness.


In light of this reality, a new book titled Participatory Grantmaking in Philanthropy: How Democratizing Decision-Making Shifts Power to Communities is a significant contribution to the field. Co-edited by philanthropy consultant Cynthia Gibson and MacArthur Foundation Managing Director of Discovery, Exploration and Programs Chris Cardona, it includes trenchant analysis, case studies penned by leaders at participatory grantmaking practitioners like the Disability Rights Fund, the Haymarket People’s Fund and theNew England Grassroots Environment Fund, and evidence-based approaches in areas ranging from climate justice to disability rights.



 
 
 

44 Comments


For a first-time visitor, a clear explanation of the account process can save time and prevent mistakes. Anyone interested in the Khel v Game platform should check the website's registration and login information. It is also useful to understand how support requests are handled. Reading the available policies before proceeding is a good habit for any online service.

Like

Shu Guo
Oct 31

Botswana’s 2015 Q4 review shows how resource dependence hits growth. Similar traceability now worries creators: platforms flag AI content via metadata. If you post edits, Remove AI Label on TikTok strips C2PA, EXIF and AI tags locally in-browser, no upload. Useful when sharing photos without false provenance flags.

Like

Stig Tom
Stig Tom
Oct 27

This review of *Inside Philanthropy* raises a fascinating point about how grantmaking stories often hide the messy, unintended consequences behind polished outcomes. It reminded me that choices—who gets funded, what gets ignored—always branch into multiple possible endings. Oddly, I had a similar feeling playing a horror visual novel called *The False Sun*, where a boy’s love becomes a nightmare and every decision unlocks one of 20 endings. If you enjoy narratives about consequence and control, the ending guides at the-falsesun.com/endings are worth a look.

Like

Stig Tom
Stig Tom
Oct 27

This is a thoughtful review of Inside Philanthropy, especially the tension between donor intent and measurable impact. It makes me want to revisit how grants and grantees are framed, and whether small nonprofits get a fair hearing. The sections on ways to give are useful too, though I’d welcome more on grassroots accountability. After heavy reading like this, I sometimes take a five-minute break to play poople online and reset before drafting notes. It’s a small way to stay sharp without losing the thread.

Like

Stig Tom
Stig Tom
Oct 27

This review of INSIDE PHILANTHROPY raises a useful question: how well do funders understand the places and communities behind their grants? Global giving works best when we can locate contexts, not just causes. I appreciated the emphasis on grantees and ways to give, but it also made me think about building geographic curiosity. A fun, low-stakes way to test that is WorldGuesser, which drops you into random street views and asks you to guess where you are. It’s free, no sign-up, and surprisingly humbling.

Like

Haymarket People's Fund

​42 Seaverns Avenue
Boston, MA 02130

info@haymarket.org 
617-522-7676

  • Facebook
bottom of page